Complaints and appeals
Complaints and Appeals
The International Journal of Advanced Research in Humanities and Law (IJREL) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, transparency, fairness, and ethical publishing. The journal follows the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) when handling complaints and appeals relating to editorial decisions, peer review, publication ethics, and other aspects of the publication process.
Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors have the right to appeal an editorial decision when they believe that the decision was based on a significant error, misunderstanding, procedural issue, or relevant information that was not adequately considered.
An appeal should not simply disagree with the editorial decision. Authors are expected to provide clear and substantive reasons and supporting evidence for their appeal.
Appeals should be submitted by email to the editorial office:
Email: editor@ijrelpub.com
An appeal letter should include, where applicable:
-
The manuscript title and submission details.
-
The specific editorial decision being appealed.
-
Clear reasons for the appeal.
-
Details of any factual, technical, or procedural errors in the decision or review.
-
Specific reasons for disagreement with the reviewers' or editors' comments.
-
Evidence of any actual or potential conflict of interest that may have affected the review process.
-
New or additional evidence, information, resources, analysis, or data that may be relevant to the editorial decision.
-
A clear explanation of how the additional information affects the manuscript or the decision.
Authors should address reviewers' and editors' comments objectively and professionally. Appeals that contain personal, offensive, or inappropriate language may not be considered.
Complaints About the Peer-Review Process
Authors may submit a complaint if they believe that the peer-review process has not been conducted fairly or in accordance with the journal's stated policies.
Complaints may concern issues such as:
-
Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
-
Breaches of confidentiality.
-
Significant procedural irregularities.
-
Inappropriate reviewer conduct.
-
Suspected bias in the review process.
-
Undue delays in the editorial or peer-review process.
-
Concerns regarding publication ethics.
Complaints should include sufficient information and supporting evidence to allow the editorial office to investigate the matter appropriately.
Handling of Appeals
The editorial office will acknowledge and review appeals in accordance with the journal's editorial policies and applicable publication-ethics principles.
The journal aims to respond to an appeal within one month of receiving a complete appeal request. The response time may be extended when additional investigation or consultation is required.
Following consideration of an appeal, the editors may:
-
Uphold the original editorial decision.
-
Request a revision of the manuscript.
-
Invite additional clarification or evidence from the authors.
-
Initiate an additional or independent peer review.
-
Reconsider the editorial decision where sufficient grounds are established.
An appeal does not guarantee a change in the original editorial decision.
Finality of Decisions
Editorial decisions following a properly considered appeal are final. A second appeal concerning the same editorial decision will normally not be considered unless substantial new evidence or a significant procedural issue is presented.
Submitting an appeal does not affect an author's ability to submit future manuscripts to IJREL, provided that the appeal and subsequent communications are conducted professionally and in accordance with the journal's policies.
Complaints About Editorial Conduct
Complaints concerning the conduct of editors or other members of the editorial team should be submitted directly to the editorial office with sufficient details and supporting evidence.
Where appropriate, the journal may refer the matter to an independent editor or another appropriate party to ensure that the complaint is considered fairly and objectively.
Contact
Authors, reviewers, and other stakeholders who wish to submit a complaint or appeal should contact:
International Journal of Advanced Research in Humanities and Law (IJREL)
Email: editor@ijrelpub.com
IJREL is committed to handling complaints and appeals confidentially, fairly, objectively, and without unnecessary delay, while respecting the rights of authors, reviewers, editors, and other participants in the scholarly publishing process.




